1. Entertainment

'Swamplandia!' by Karen Russell - Book Review

About.com Rating 3 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

From

Swamplandia by Karen Russell

Swamplandia by Karen Russell

Knopf
  • Swamplandia! was published February 1, 2011
  • Publisher: Knopf
  • 336 pages

'Swamplandia!' Review

Swamplandia! -- What a great title. It got my attention. So did Karen Russell’s writing. Can she put together some fabulous sentences. Russell’s got a nifty knack for descriptions and metaphors. Her characters are originals -- spunky, bizarre and heartfelt. And what a wickedly mischievous setting, an amusement park located on an island in the humidity drenched state of Florida! There are a lot of worthy exclamations here.

Russell’s tale begins with Ava, the daughter of Chief Bigtree who owns and runs Swamplandia! with his beautiful wife and Ava’s mom, Hilola, who wrestles the alligators. Ava also has an older brother named Kiwi and an older sister named Osceola. All of the family members live on the island in the park and daily try to keep the ticket buyers thrilled. But then, sadly, Hilola contracts cancer and dies. Who will wrestle the alligators now? More importantly, who will wrestle the demons that are plaguing this family?

This story was ripe to be incredible. But was it? Sadly, no. I was getting a bit distracted a third of the way in. There is a melancholy that seeps into these pages that is hard to wrestle away. At the beginning, the book is told from Ava’s perspective, and she is a wonderful lead. But when her father and brother leave and she is left to find her older sister who has become engrossed in the occult and dating ghosts, the story whiplashes about.

The narrative focus switches between Kiwi on the mainland and Ava searching for Osceola in the swamp. While this mirrors how disjointed and lost the family feels, it also begins to lose the reader in the process. Ava begins to encounter some seemingly real perils, but the magical aspects keep the reader questioning and the story circling. Down a drain? Sometimes it feels like all this may be going nowhere. One moment the reader may feel nervous excitement, but the next may be an onslaught nausea like being tucked into a death roll with no hope for escape.

Let Swamplandia! be an example that creativity and eccentricity do not necessarily keep a reader’s attention. In fact, Russell may have too many description-filled sentences mucking about. This story needed a little bit more bite and thrift to make it the classic it could have been. Russell is a new talent on the horizon. Let’s just hope she gets a better editor that can chomp down when necessary next time.

Reading Swamplandia! with a book club? Check out these Swamplandia Book Club Discussion Questions

Disclosure: A review copy was provided by the publisher. For more information, please see our Ethics Policy.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.