1. Entertainment

Discuss in my forum

'Noah's Compass' by Anne Tyler - Book Review

About.com Rating 3 Star Rating
User Rating 5 Star Rating (1 Review) Write a review

By , About.com Guide

Noah's Compass by Anne Tyler

'Noah's Compass' by Anne Tyler

Knopf Doubleday

The Bottom Line

Noah's Compass by Anne Tyler is a novel about Liam Pennywell, a schoolteacher who was forced to retire at 61, but who doesn't really mind because he never felt particularly fulfilled. The first night in his new condominium, though, he is attacked and wakes up in the hospital unable to remember what happened. He becomes obsessed with retrieving his memory, which leads him to reflect on the purpose of his life and what might make him happy.
<!--#echo encoding="none" var="lcp" -->

Pros

  • Tyler's writes well, creating and engaging and easy to read story.
  • Tyler suceeds in moving a character based novel forward without many plot turns.

Cons

  • There is no amazing revelation or plot turn -- you may crave more of a point.
  • The main character and thoughts on life are kind of depressing.

Description

  • 'Noah's Compass' by Anne Tyler was released in January 2010.
  • Publisher: Knopf Doubleday
  • 288 Pages

Guide Review - 'Noah's Compass' by Anne Tyler - Book Review

Kudos to Anne Tyler for writing a book about a character who is not especially interesting and a plot that is slow, but that still made me want to read chapter after chapter each night. Her descriptions of people and situations demonstrate keen observational skills. Get inside any person's head and you are bound to dig up interesting and thought provoking insights about human nature and the meaning of life. Noah's Compass certainly gave me things to ponder, and Tyler made me care about a character who did not even care very much about himself. I don't regret reading Noah's Compass. It was a worthwhile use of time.

Would I, however, recommend it? Probably not, if for no other reason than I am likely to forget it by the time someone asks for a recommendation. It was a well written story, but it wasn't particularly insightful, particularly moving, particularly memorable. I understand that a grand ending would have undermined Tyler's understated message, but I still left the novel wanting something more.

Most people who I know want a book that is gratifying on many levels -- entertaining, thoughtful, not too hard to read. Noah's Compass is better suited to those who don't expect quite so much from a book.

<!--#echo encoding="none" var="lcp" -->

User Reviews

 5 out of 5
A beautifully subtle book, Member gamoi77

I really loved this book and was hooked from the beginning. Liam is a sixty-one year old teacher who has been recently made redundant and has downsized to a smaller apartment opposite a shopping mall on the Baltimore Beltway. Unfulfilled, and unneeded by his family he is at a loss as to how to fill his days. One fears at this point that the novel will sink into the heaviness of depression but it then takes a surprising turn. Liam wakes up to find himself in a hospital and doesn't know why. It turns out that he had been attacked the previous night by an intruder but he has no recollection of the incident. He becomes obsessed with wanting to fill the gap in his memory. You wonder if the novel is going to be about trying to uncover what happened that night, almost in the style of a 'whodunnit'. It doesn't take that direction however. It becomes more of an attempt by Liam (and us) to understand all the other gaps in his life ( Why is there so little contact with his three daughters? Why did he end up teaching fifth grade if he was capable of something more enjoyable to him?). He connives to 'bump into' the personal assistant of a local businessman suffering from dementia in the illogical hope that she can jog his memory too. He feels a “sudden flood of affection” for Eunice in spite of her “errant bra strap... and the headlamp look of her eyes behind her big glasses”. He enters a relationship with her and experiences a lovely, sweet connection that leads him to remember previous connections and to recognise that not only was he not present to the events of the night of the attack, but that he was not present to most of his own life. Ernest Hemingway once wrote : “If a writer knows what he is talking about he may omit things he knows. The dignity of the movement of an iceberg is due to only one-ninth of it being above the water.” The dignity of this novel owes a lot to the power of omission. Absence permeates the novel and is a major theme– the writing style is minimalist and Liam has lost his job, his memory and has little connection with family and friends. Ms. Tyler has done a wonderful job of capturing the emptiness and barely concealed despair of many modern day lives without creating a depressing read. This is a touching, gently humorous and ultimately optimistic book . It is the first Anne Tyler book I have read - I look forward to reading the rest.

Write a review

1 out of 1 people found this helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes | No

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.