1. Entertainment

Discuss in my forum

'When We Were Romans' by Matthew Kneale - Book Review

About.com Rating 4 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

By , About.com Guide

'When We Were Romans' by Matthew Kneale

'When We Were Romans' by Matthew Kneale

Nan A. Talese

The Bottom Line

When We Were Romans by Matthew Kneale is a short, but powerful novel told from the perspective of a nine-year-old boy named Lawrence. As in The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time by Mark Haddon, When We Were Romans is told in the young narrator's voice, complete with run on sentences, misspellings and tangents about emperors and outer space -- two of Lawrence's favorite topics. Indeed, Lawrence is what makes When We Were Romans such a captivating book. Readers will feel his hopes and fears, and desperately route for a happy ending that our adult minds know is impossible.

Pros

  • Kneale creates a convincing and likable child narrator
  • The narrator and story are unique and engrossing
  • The story moves through dread and hope well

Cons

  • It takes some time to get used to the narrator's vernacular -- run on sentences and misspellings

Description

  • 'When We Were Romans' by Matthew Kneale was published by Nan A. Talese.
  • Published: July 2008
  • 224 Pages

Guide Review - 'When We Were Romans' by Matthew Kneale - Book Review

When We Were Romans has a relatively simple plot: Lawrence's parents are divorced, and his mother is convinced that his father is planning to hurt them. The family packs quickly, and leaves England on a road trip to Rome in search of safety. Once in Rome, they struggle to create a new life, with the trouble they tried to leave behind pursuing them.

It is not, however, the plot that drives this novel; it is the endearing narrator. Lawrence is a convincing nine-year-old, but he is also wise beyond his years. His interactions with his mother and baby sister are believable and telling.

Ten pages into When We Were Romans, I was having trouble getting into the story, and thought there was a good chance I'd be let down. By page 30, I was hooked. When We Were Romans is a quick, engrossing read that has enough meat for a book club without requiring too much mental energy.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.